Yup. I had no issues with the OEM one. The Eagle Eye one started working out of its groove in less than a week. I tried to glue it in at the ends because that's where it would first try to pop out. But I couldn't get it to stay. I removed the flap from my OEM wing and installed it into the EE one. But it wouldn't stay, either. So I've been running without ever since. The only consequence that I can see is that more dirt washes into the space between the hatch sheet metal and the weather seal. It doesn't leak, or seem to allow any more road or wind noise in. Still, I'd rather have the flap than not. The one I ordered comes with a flap. Hopefully it's in good shape, so I don't have to touch it.