Rear diff fluid

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Dantheman1540

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2020
Posts
4,973
Reaction score
10,818
Location
Sugar Loaf Mountain
I pulled apart the carrier from my new 14b that had the markings on the spider gears. Heres some pics, they look like it could be shock load stress like @Rocket Man suggested.

Also glad I didn't plan on running these
20200815_182109.jpg
20200815_182114.jpg
 

Rocket Man

Mark
Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2014
Posts
26,678
Reaction score
52,943
Location
Oregon

Dantheman1540

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2020
Posts
4,973
Reaction score
10,818
Location
Sugar Loaf Mountain
I wonder if that could be from using the wrong fluid like that article suggested. Seems possible I guess.

I'd say very possible. Truck was a WT model and judging by the etching on the pinion someone had tampered with it. When I cracked the cover the fluid was really gross, lots of sludge and the magnet was extremely fuzzy. Nothing big enough to feel just fuzzy mush.

I wouldn't be surprised if some jack wagon grabbed whatever was on the shelf.
 

roc1967

TYF Newbie
Joined
Nov 11, 2014
Posts
20
Reaction score
10
Location
Indiana
It bothers me that GM specs different fluids for front and rear diffs. Is there any harm in using the rear diff fluid (SAE 75W-90 Synthetic - GM PN 12378261) on the front diff, originally spec'ing SAE 80W-90 (GM PN 1052271)?
 

Rocket Man

Mark
Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2014
Posts
26,678
Reaction score
52,943
Location
Oregon
It bothers me that GM specs different fluids for front and rear diffs. Is there any harm in using the rear diff fluid (SAE 75W-90 Synthetic - GM PN 12378261) on the front diff, originally spec'ing SAE 80W-90 (GM PN 1052271)?
There’s a reason they call for different fluids. I’m pretty sure you’d be more bothered if your front diff wore out from using the wrong stuff.
 
OP
OP
T

Tiredmechanic23

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2019
Posts
198
Reaction score
137
If I’m not mistaken, the G80’s do not need the friction modifier additive.

@Rocket Man or @Jolly Roger, either of you want to share what you learned about additives on the G80 differentials since you both went down the rabbit hole on this one recently?

Good to know. So no change from the older G80s in the 90s trucks. Ill be changing fluids this weekend then. Appreciate it.
 

JonnyTahoe

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2011
Posts
1,249
Reaction score
779
Location
Minneapolis
for some that may be. I take suggestions and research from there. Ive always gone about things that way. Take suggestions and further research from there.

Big question I have now as things have changed since my last GM truck/SUV. Do the G80 on the K2 platform require LSD additives or no?
You mean Limited Slip additive.
 
OP
OP
T

Tiredmechanic23

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2019
Posts
198
Reaction score
137
Ill try...
LOTS of heated debate and confusion out there about this. It doesn't help that GM used the G80 RPO code to designate both posi/limited slip differentials (on cars) AND Eaton Gov-Lock locking differentials (found on trucks).

My personal conclusion after spending around 10 hours on the subject reading forum conversations, phone calls, opinions and hypothesis's I could find, and like you said following those links further into there individual rabbit holes......

The G80 Gov-Lock does not require any friction modifier or additive.

GM considers any additive introduced into the G80-GL a contaminate that may cause the diff to fail by delaying the engagement of the locking mechanism (bad) and or causing chattering/shuttering (also bad).


While the Eaton G80 Gov-Lock does have differential clutch plates and works like a limited slip diff, it was not designed to need or use a friction modifier/ additive.
Several service bulletins from GM have been released on this matter.

BUT......

Upon calling a few local shops I found that most if not all of them still use an additive when replacing fluid in a G80 Gov-Loc.

When I asked why they said.... "because its a limited slip differential and that's what limited slip differentials take!"


furthermore, the internet is full of people claiming that they have used a additive in their G80GL and it works just fine.
So I call other lube shops, in other cities and states and received a motley assortment of answers but non that were definitive.



The best answer I got ended up being from an old friend of mine who I had called and left a message with. A regular at the racetrack, the old gear-head type...
He said....

"The reason people are not having problems when an additive is used, is because their not using the locking portion of the differential. Most of these people drive around to work and back and wouldn't know what "diff chatter" was if it bit them in the a$$.
Now people who actually USE their Gov-Locks locking feature, like those who 4x4 or have a heavy foot (especially on loose soil, gravel or snow),..."


He went on to explain that this diff locker works with RPM and the additive (just like the service bulletin said..) will keep the locker from engaging when its supposed to. When and if it DOES engage at a now higher RPM it was designed for... BOOM!

"You now have what has become known as the GM Gov-bomb."
"Run a 75/90 in the rear with no modifier and it'll be good to go!"

He also noted that the reason most "professionals" or lube techs say they run a additive in the G80 is because the "screen" tells them to. Somewhere along the line the confusion of the posi-track G80 RPO code is getting crossed with the Gov-Lock G80 RPO instructions....(imagine that) maybe even at the time the information was written into the system to begin with.

SRkOL52t.png

Sadly I knew all the older up to atleast 08 G80 Gov loc setups did not require the fluid but the shop I last worked at failed to listen. I worked for a major refinery here on forklifts and all company trucks. around 150 lifts and at least that in GM trucks ranging from 80s models to 2017s. Anything newer than 08 still went to dealer. Anyways every time I did rear end work I would request non additive fluid. Boss or parts guy would order it and get me additive included fluids or a separate tube of additive. I kept explaining it is not required and is bad to use. Always got the same answer "we have always used it and never had issues"... Hmmm maybe thats why we replace so many rear ends when they blow up.

But I did no know if things had changed on these newer models or not and wanted to be clear. I know exactly what I plan to use at this point and appreciate everyone's info.

I think he is referring to the munched up spider gears. Saying they are shot and either scrap or could be welded up to make a Lincoln Locker.

I see that now lol. That was my fault I missed a few post.
 

Jolly Roger

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2018
Posts
423
Reaction score
583
How much differential noise is normal?
Im getting a whining noise at around 35-40 MPH now after the shop replaced the pinion gear. I dont remember what normal sounds like. Can anyone here actually hear there rear end through certain RPM ranges?
 

JonnyTahoe

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2011
Posts
1,249
Reaction score
779
Location
Minneapolis
How much differential noise is normal?
Im getting a whining noise at around 35-40 MPH now after the shop replaced the pinion gear. I dont remember what normal sounds like. Can anyone here actually hear there rear end through certain RPM ranges?
Mostly at highway steady speeds. 275k will do that.
 
Last edited:

Forum statistics

Threads
137,724
Posts
1,990,451
Members
102,714
Latest member
briannorris

Latest posts

Back
Top