Quick Tire Question

[AmunRoo]

So... I'm in the market for a new set of tires. I'm trying to find something economical but decent in the performance aspect. I happen to come across the ATTURO Trail Blade ATS and they aren't that expensive but, i've always felt that you get what you pay for. Has anyone bought these tires before? The reviews i've seen are mixed. Some people complain heavily about them because of balance issues and others rant and rave about them. The problem being that these are people with different types of vehicles. Also, i'm looking at size 305/35/24. If anyone here has bought a set of these, i'd love to know your impression of these tires. My other options are

Atturo Trail Blade ATS $199.00

General Grabber UHP $277.00

Nexen Rodian HP $296.00

Falken Ziex STZ05 $329.00

Yokohama Parada Spec-X $362.00

Toyo Proxes STIII $366.00

General GMAX AS-07 $384.00

Even If you guys have had any experience with any tires on the list, i'd love to hear about it. Also, i'm not sure if my post is in the right place as i couldn't find a tire thread. As always, any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

 

[Geotrash]

So... I'm in the market for a new set of tires. I'm trying to find something economical but decent in the performance aspect. I happen to come across the ATTURO Trail Blade ATS and they aren't that expensive but, i've always felt that you get what you pay for. Has anyone bought these tires before? The reviews i've seen are mixed. Some people complain heavily about them because of balance issues and others rant and rave about them. The problem being that these are people with different types of vehicles. Also, i'm looking at size 305/35/24. If anyone here has bought a set of these, i'd love to know your impression of these tires. My other options are

Atturo Trail Blade ATS $199.00

General Grabber UHP $277.00

Nexen Rodian HP $296.00

Falken Ziex STZ05 $329.00

Yokohama Parada Spec-X $362.00

Toyo Proxes STIII $366.00

General GMAX AS-07 $384.00

Even If you guys have had any experience with any tires on the list, i'd love to hear about it. Also, i'm not sure if my post is in the right place as i couldn't find a tire thread. As always, any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

I don't have experience with any of those, but I'll add one more to your list: Continental TerrainContact H/T. Word on the street is that it's so good, it caused Michelin to finally redesign the Defender LTX. I have a set of each (the Michelins and the Continentals) on each of our two Yukon XL Denali's in 20" size, and the Continentals are superb.

 

[Tahoe14]

Have you tried a Google search review for any of the tires listed.

 

[AmunRoo]

Have you tried a Google search review for any of the tires listed.

yep, i have checked reviews on various sites. The problem is that they are all over the board. They all have positive heavy reviews but they are for a variety of vehicles. The all also have concerning bad reviews. Balance issues, out of round issues, noise issues, premature wear issues, etc... This makes it hard to gauge what i'm looking at when a lot of positive reviews are from jeep people, for example. Or from some guy in a Honda ridgeline.

The plus side, if i get the Atturo tires and they end up being a heaping pile, Discount tire will swap them out for something else and i'd only have to pay the difference. As long as it's within 30 days. Unless there's a lot of fine print which i'll say i read, but really wont lol

 

[t_bergman]

Disclaimer: I have a 2500 and tires will feel different.

I used to run Goodyear A/T 2's which were fairly noisy but I stuck it out on my '09; they were great all terrains however and didn't cause the mileage to tank. Ran through two sets actually. ~55k and then at 110k.

Upgraded to Michelin LTX A/T 2's and they are incredible; really good traction, quiet, and don't ride rough even at 50/60 psi. I'll be buying these again and took them with me from my '09 onto my '13. Dealership recommended them (I trust the service manager) and they've been great; never any issues and I drive 55-95mph depending on the conditions and they probably get 1,000-1,500 miles of true off road/deep snow use per year.

My wife also has Michelin LTX A/T 2's on her '18 Jeep Wrangler; upgraded when the stock Michelin's were getting worn at approximately 40k and now has 58k and they look brand new. She reported a noticeable difference traction compared with the stock and hasn't complained about noise, rough ride and I keep them at 35 psi.

Edit: I need to learn how to spell.

 

[Tahoe14]

I would probably lean towards trying the Discount tire offer, I have read reviews on Michelin tires which are suppose to be the best and most people love them but not everyone. I think it comes down to personal taste. Good luck.

 

[j91z28d1]

I don't have experience with any of those, but I'll add one more to your list: Continental TerrainContact H/T. Word on the street is that it's so good, it caused Michelin to finally redesign the Defender LTX. I have a set of each (the Michelins and the Continentals) on each of our two Yukon XL Denali's in 20" size, and the Continentals are superb.

huh. I'm going to be in the market soon. read a little on both and saw tire rack test. I like the sound of the continental tires.

guess you can't go wrong with either thou. mine will be in 17s so not sure how 20s compare, but have you noticed which ones are quieter?

 

[Trey Hardy]

So... I'm in the market for a new set of tires. I'm trying to find something economical but decent in the performance aspect. I happen to come across the ATTURO Trail Blade ATS and they aren't that expensive but, i've always felt that you get what you pay for. Has anyone bought these tires before? The reviews i've seen are mixed. Some people complain heavily about them because of balance issues and others rant and rave about them. The problem being that these are people with different types of vehicles. Also, i'm looking at size 305/35/24. If anyone here has bought a set of these, i'd love to know your impression of these tires. My other options are

Atturo Trail Blade ATS $199.00

General Grabber UHP $277.00

Nexen Rodian HP $296.00

Falken Ziex STZ05 $329.00

Yokohama Parada Spec-X $362.00

Toyo Proxes STIII $366.00

General GMAX AS-07 $384.00

Even If you guys have had any experience with any tires on the list, i'd love to hear about it. Also, i'm not sure if my post is in the right place as i couldn't find a tire thread. As always, any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

I’ve had the atturo trail blade Mt and they have been great and lasted a good while.
My buddy had general grabbers with no complaints
Dads always ran Toyos and he’s loved them he got a set of Firestone’s and they diddnt last no time compared to his Toyos

 

[Charlie207]

Have you tried a Google search review for any of the tires listed.

The problems with tire reviews are: 99% are paid shills (buy this, it's amazing!!!), and the other .5% are by people that have no idea how to review a boat anchor, let alone a dynamic piece of equipment, like a tire.

Due to multiple climates and driving types, tire recommendations can be tricky.

 

[Geotrash]

huh. I'm going to be in the market soon. read a little on both and saw tire rack test. I like the sound of the continental tires.

guess you can't go wrong with either thou. mine will be in 17s so not sure how 20s compare, but have you noticed which ones are quieter?

I have listened for this while driving both Yukons and they're indistinguishable to my ears. I also expected the XL rated Continentals to have a stiffer ride but they don't. Seems that they may have finally unseated the reigning champion LTX. Hopefully they'll last a long time too. Also, while they are the same width as the LTX's at the bead, the sidewalls on the Continentals are significantly wider - perhaps a half inch or more distance between the bulges on both sides of the tire, as is the tread, giving the impression that they're a wider tire than the LTX. They also perform better in beach sand than the LTX without airing down.

The problems with tire reviews are: 99% are paid shills (buy this, it's amazing!!!), and the other .5% are by people that have no idea how to review a boat anchor, let alone a dynamic piece of equipment, like a tire.

Due to multiple climates and driving types, tire recommendations can be tricky.

Yup. Precisely why I came here to ask for input a few months ago before I bought the Continentals.

 

[91RS]

None of those. Never go cheap on what connects the car to the road. Michelins or Continentals only.

 

[Charlie207]

I have listened for this while driving both Yukons and they're indistinguishable to my ears. I also expected the XL rated Continentals to have a stiffer ride but they don't. Seems that they may have finally unseated the reigning champion LTX. Hopefully they'll last a long time too. Also, while they are the same width as the LTX's at the bead, the sidewalls on the Continentals are significantly wider - perhaps a half inch or more distance between the bulges on both sides of the tire, as is the tread, giving the impression that they're a wider tire than the LTX. They also perform better in beach sand than the LTX without airing down.


Yup. Precisely why I came here to ask for input a few months ago before I bought the Continentals.

Doesn't Continental own General? IIRC, I think I read that when I bought some AT2s back in the day for my old Pathfinder.

 

[Charlie207]

None of those. Never go cheap on what connects the car to the road. Michelins or Continentals only.

It really depends what you need them for, especially if there is mud/snow/off-road factored into the equation.

Sure, Michelin and Continental make nice tires, but they don't have the market cornered on quality.

 

[91RS]

Yes, they do. I’ve been dealing with tires professionally for over 15 years.

 

[Padraig]

On my 2013 Yukon XL I was running Nitto tires and very pleased. When the tires on my 2023 need replaced It will likely be with Nitto.

Padraig

 

[Doubeleive]

So... I'm in the market for a new set of tires. I'm trying to find something economical but decent in the performance aspect. I happen to come across the ATTURO Trail Blade ATS and they aren't that expensive but, i've always felt that you get what you pay for. Has anyone bought these tires before? The reviews i've seen are mixed. Some people complain heavily about them because of balance issues and others rant and rave about them. The problem being that these are people with different types of vehicles. Also, i'm looking at size 305/35/24. If anyone here has bought a set of these, i'd love to know your impression of these tires. My other options are

Atturo Trail Blade ATS $199.00

General Grabber UHP $277.00

Nexen Rodian HP $296.00

Falken Ziex STZ05 $329.00

Yokohama Parada Spec-X $362.00

Toyo Proxes STIII $366.00

General GMAX AS-07 $384.00

Even If you guys have had any experience with any tires on the list, i'd love to hear about it. Also, i'm not sure if my post is in the right place as i couldn't find a tire thread. As always, any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

as you noted tire ratings are all over the place, which sucks because not everyone drives the same nor the same vehicle
another issue is the size 24" wheels. (not my personal choice) I bend wheels just running 22's, less rubber and sidewall affects the ride and grip, 305's atleast save from rim rash a little. the only thing 24's have going for them is they "look nice".
your probably going to have to just find a happy medium somewhere between cost and popularity.
I have used the nexen roadian at, a different tire yes but same brand and I would buy them again
I have used the toyo at's also, slickest tire I ever used and this has strayed me away from the brand probably for life.

also this 30 day offer is not enough really to judge a tire unless they are just garbage out the gate in which case it would be in your favor. some tires do not show there true self until some miles have been put on them. primarily in the road noise department they may start out great and then 10k later they sound like a bad set of bearings.

tires basically come in 3 types, soft-medium-hard
a hard tire gets you more miles (less wear, less grip)
a medium tire gets you more grip (medium wear, more grip)
a soft tire (wears fast and less grip)

that's just my .02 cents from a driver that generally drives with on-road performance in mind, my personal choice for a on-road vehicle will always be a medium tire
I will always choose performance over mileage, tires are a wear item.

 

[mikez71]

that's just my .02 cents from a driver that generally drives with on-road performance in mind, my personal choice for a on-road vehicle will always be a medium tire
I will always choose performance over mileage, tires are a wear item.

Totally agree! No point in having good tread on hard dried out rubber..
(I don't put enough miles in to really judge)

 

[Joseph Garcia]

So... I'm in the market for a new set of tires. I'm trying to find something economical but decent in the performance aspect. I happen to come across the ATTURO Trail Blade ATS and they aren't that expensive but, i've always felt that you get what you pay for. Has anyone bought these tires before? The reviews i've seen are mixed. Some people complain heavily about them because of balance issues and others rant and rave about them. The problem being that these are people with different types of vehicles. Also, i'm looking at size 305/35/24. If anyone here has bought a set of these, i'd love to know your impression of these tires. My other options are

Atturo Trail Blade ATS $199.00

General Grabber UHP $277.00

Nexen Rodian HP $296.00

Falken Ziex STZ05 $329.00

Yokohama Parada Spec-X $362.00

Toyo Proxes STIII $366.00

General GMAX AS-07 $384.00

Even If you guys have had any experience with any tires on the list, i'd love to hear about it. Also, i'm not sure if my post is in the right place as i couldn't find a tire thread. As always, any help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

You did not tell us what surfaces you normally drive on, or if you plan to do any semi-serious off-roading. Answers to these have a major impact on the selection of tires that will meet your needs.

If your riving is predominantly on paved surfaces, than I'd recommend Michelin Defenders LTX M/S. They are a bit pricey, but they are good for 70,000 miles, and nothing that the NH winters have thrown at them was an issue.

 

[j91z28d1]

I have listened for this while driving both Yukons and they're indistinguishable to my ears. I also expected the XL rated Continentals to have a stiffer ride but they don't. Seems that they may have finally unseated the reigning champion LTX. Hopefully they'll last a long time too. Also, while they are the same width as the LTX's at the bead, the sidewalls on the Continentals are significantly wider - perhaps a half inch or more distance between the bulges on both sides of the tire, as is the tread, giving the impression that they're a wider tire than the LTX. They also perform better in beach sand than the LTX without airing down.


Yup. Precisely why I came here to ask for input a few months ago before I bought the Continentals.

thank you.

seems like the continentals fit what I'm looking for perfectly. in my 17in size they offer both sl and xl. I don't tow like you guys do, so sl seems to be the way to go for me. we mostly never see any snow or really cold Temps either but lots of wet roads, if tire rack test crosses over to my size, I'll take the bias towards wet.

$213 shipped from tire rack feels like a good price too.

 

[mountie]

Oh, boy o boy....... Tires...... So many choices....... I bought new, a 2016 Infiniti QX50. Factory- installed Dunlops / 18". They handled well and quiet. Perfect tire choice to 'smooze' a buyer.....
They were well over $200 each. No warranty. They lasted 20,000 miles. Infinity chose the Dunlops for the "feel" at time of purchase. They are junk, considering the fast wear.

I have been doing business with Discount Tire since 1990. They have experience and I trust their advice. When I tell them I will want to buy a set of Michelin's, they let me know what month Michelin has their ( 4 times a year) 'coupon-discount' so I save money....