How much $$ do you put into your truck before saying enough is enough?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

OP
OP
Derick

Derick

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2018
Posts
632
Reaction score
696
Location
Indy Suburbs
Well this is a second vehicle for me. My winter ride, and tow rig. That said, I dont particularly want to have it broken down at any point. I would also drive it daily if I got these things worked out. Technically I dont have a note on it, but I sort of do. The loan that I had to get the sequoia got wrapped into an unsecured consolidation loan for much lower interest rate.

In reality, the grand I'll spend on this TC is a lot less than a new trans or a motor...so for that I'm grateful. I'm also having my mechanic replace the oil pressure sensor and screen - and hopefully it returns back to it's spec pressure. That said, it will be another 800 bucks to replace the oil pump I'm sure. But when that's done, I feel like it will finally be reliable.
 

MajorJakkov

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2017
Posts
208
Reaction score
413
Location
Danger Zone
serious question..I'm genuinely curious since it seems the general consensus here is that it would be frowned upon to sell or trade a used car that needs some work

how much more would you pay for a truck that just had some repairs vs one that simply left the repairs to the next owner? for instance if $1500 worth of suspension parts were just swapped out to clear the dash light, would you pay an extra $1500 for the vehicle? to me, it seems like it would be a bad financial decision for the previous owner to fix things only to sell it shortly after
 

ZACHBORIS

TYF Newbie
Joined
Feb 11, 2016
Posts
19
Reaction score
10
serious question..I'm genuinely curious since it seems the general consensus here is that it would be frowned upon to sell or trade a used car that needs some work

how much more would you pay for a truck that just had some repairs vs one that simply left the repairs to the next owner? for instance if $1500 worth of suspension parts were just swapped out to clear the dash light, would you pay an extra $1500 for the vehicle? to me, it seems like it would be a bad financial decision for the previous owner to fix things only to sell it shortly after

I would not pay more than any blue book / nada value, and that value of course would be dependent upon the vehicles condition. So, this "car" blue books at 5K in excellent condition, and the owner just put in $1500 in parts, the blue book is still 5K, not $6,500. Now, if that car is 5K in excellent condition and needs $1500 worth of work, this car should now cost $3500.
If i am reading your question correctly.

Now , if there are add ons like a supercharger, and other mechanical upgrades, that owner may be able to fetch a little more, but only to the right buyer...
 
OP
OP
Derick

Derick

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2018
Posts
632
Reaction score
696
Location
Indy Suburbs
I would not pay more than any blue book / nada value, and that value of course would be dependent upon the vehicles condition. So, this "car" blue books at 5K in excellent condition, and the owner just put in $1500 in parts, the blue book is still 5K, not $6,500. Now, if that car is 5K in excellent condition and needs $1500 worth of work, this car should now cost $3500.
If i am reading your question correctly.

Now , if there are add ons like a supercharger, and other mechanical upgrades, that owner may be able to fetch a little more, but only to the right buyer...

I agree with this to an extent. If you're at that ~150-200k point, then blue book is for calculating for 150-200k parts. If you have replaced a fair amount of wear parts to bring it back to spec, I would expect to be fairly compensated for that. That said, as was mentioned above, it does not behoove someone to put in big money only to sell it. Grease up the joints enough to sell and ship it down the road.

Similarly, if I just put in a $6000 jasper motor, you better believe I'm not going to take blue book. Again, blue book accounts for used parts in accordance to the mileage provided....I'm not going to just throw in a brand new motor and expect nothing in return.
 
OP
OP
Derick

Derick

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2018
Posts
632
Reaction score
696
Location
Indy Suburbs
So this happened:
570062842.jpg
Got a call from the mechanic saying the flex plate needed to be replaced too...thats what he found.

Also that the Tc had some writing on it that made no sense...
570062908.jpg
 

jsoltren

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Posts
159
Reaction score
95
I keep a spreadsheet with two columns.

One column is the market resale value. I update it monthly.

The other is the total expenditures for maintenance. I update that, well, hopefully never, but in practice about monthly.

When total expenditure exceeds value, or the rate of expenditure consistently spikes, it's time for it to go.

How do you value your time and money? If you have the time to get parts from the salvage yard, have hookups to get distributor pricing on parts, and do all your own labor, maintenance will stay less expensive. If you farm everything out, every little thing is a $500 repair ticket.

If you're actively worried about the condition of the vehicle, to the extent that you're worried about doing normal things with it (like hauling kids), it's time for it to go. Cut your losses. Sunk cost fallacy.

If on the other hand repairs and upgrades give you the joy of working with your hands and being satisfied with your work, that has enough value that maybe you don't sell it.

Up to you to know what works for you.
 

Jorge1313

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2018
Posts
225
Reaction score
64
I don’t know about you guy but where I love the Tahoe used with 45 k miles on ran up very expensive like 38 k when. New Tahoe ran for 45k new not 3 yrs old with no warrenty . I always have brought used but the Tahoe used are so darn expensive I’d rather spill out and extra 5 k and ride it new . Used Tahoe in Florida all I saw where very expensive with high milage
 

homesick

The Best Me I Can Be
Navy Air Force
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Posts
4,677
Reaction score
13,237
Another factor here is parts availability.

I bought this '95 Tahoe last spring. My motorcycle is even older, a '93 model. I've had it for 15 years.

You have to be willing to scrounge, repair, and improvise parts as your machines age. Enthusiast forums like this one can be life savers.

joe
 

Matthew Jeschke

Full Access Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2017
Posts
2,344
Reaction score
1,747
Location
Sahuarita, Arizona
Problem is you must be putting in wrong dollars... when its upgrade there is never a cap on spending lol


Sry just saw title of your post and couldnt help but say something ;)

Sent from my SM-A505U using Tapatalk
 

EddieC

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Posts
959
Reaction score
792
Have you priced a new replacement? That made it an easy decision to keep mine forever. A bit of money every year or two is nothing compared to those payments.
 
OP
OP
Derick

Derick

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2018
Posts
632
Reaction score
696
Location
Indy Suburbs
Have you priced a new replacement? That made it an easy decision to keep mine forever. A bit of money every year or two is nothing compared to those payments.
You know, you say that buuuuuut. I started thinking on it more. My trans pump is on its way out. Might be a month, might be a year, who knows....but lets say I sell my honda. It's 400 bucks a month....I put about 4 tanks of fuel in, @ 2.30ish, @13gal so about 120 bucks a month in fuel. Keeping in mind I do drive the burb ALSO, I put in another 80 bucks or so in fuel, per month in there. So, my tanks yield the same amount of driving, about ~400 miles. But the burb is about 36 gal, at that same 2.30 is 331 bucks a month, plus that original 80 that I was already putting into it, so 410 per mo in fuel. That quite literally my car payment. :( Might as well keep the honda, I'm not really saving anything outside of insurance costs....
 

EddieC

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Posts
959
Reaction score
792
You know, you say that buuuuuut. I started thinking on it more. My trans pump is on its way out. Might be a month, might be a year, who knows....but lets say I sell my honda. It's 400 bucks a month....I put about 4 tanks of fuel in, @ 2.30ish, @13gal so about 120 bucks a month in fuel. Keeping in mind I do drive the burb ALSO, I put in another 80 bucks or so in fuel, per month in there. So, my tanks yield the same amount of driving, about ~400 miles. But the burb is about 36 gal, at that same 2.30 is 331 bucks a month, plus that original 80 that I was already putting into it, so 410 per mo in fuel. That quite literally my car payment. :( Might as well keep the honda, I'm not really saving anything outside of insurance costs....


I thought you meant before buying another one. They definitely are not economical on fuel but if you have a use for a big vehicle, that's ours of choice. We need a good cargo area for our needs, so we stick with it. We use the gas miser when the space is not needed.

According to our tax assessor, the Tahoe is better than investing in stocks.
 
OP
OP
Derick

Derick

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2018
Posts
632
Reaction score
696
Location
Indy Suburbs
I thought you meant before buying another one. They definitely are not economical on fuel but if you have a use for a big vehicle, that's ours of choice. We need a good cargo area for our needs, so we stick with it. We use the gas miser when the space is not needed.

According to our tax assessor, the Tahoe is better than investing in stocks.

Yeah, I was juggling a few ideas...One was sell everything, buy something cheap and reliable.......the other idea, the one that I was referencing here was sell the honda, keep the burb........nothing written in stone at the moment. Lots of things in flux in my life too. A few months ago, I didnt 'need' the burb, and I was trying to sell it, and I sold my 18' 12k# trailer.....well what did I do not too long ago? bought some commercial mowers and want to mow lawns come spring....so I need it again! Grrr. I know, just rambling on this one.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
137,815
Posts
1,992,824
Members
102,795
Latest member
Drewphil
Back
Top