Mandatory Onstar?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

selectsplat

Full Access Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2021
Posts
220
Reaction score
235
Would be good to hear from a 2022 driver who let their data plan expire...
22 High Country.

My data plan lapsed, wireless CarPlay continued to work. What I lost was some features in the built navigation (not carplay) such as speed limit, traffic and hazards, and the speed limit sign on the hud. Also lost google voice assistant and some other features of the infotainment system (apps)
 
OP
OP
P

Polo08816

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2010
Posts
808
Reaction score
342
22 High Country.

My data plan lapsed, wireless CarPlay continued to work. What I lost was some features in the built navigation (not carplay) such as speed limit, traffic and hazards, and the speed limit sign on the hud. Also lost google voice assistant and some other features of the infotainment system (apps)
But it would make too much sense for the entire system to just tether off of your cell phone data plan....
 

Baja_Bob

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2022
Posts
300
Reaction score
159
Location
Michigan
In 5-6 years there will be Yukons on used lots for sale with operating systems incompatible with the newest updates at the time. Half of the options won't work, I can see it now.
 

Seamus

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2019
Posts
308
Reaction score
418
Location
Palm Beach
I sometimes have a hard time understanding all this disdain for OnStar and what it can do for our personal safety. Of course I get it that people don't want to pay for these services for a number of their own personal reasons, so I get that part. At the age of 73, I embrace improving technology and am willing to pay for all those safety features offered for what I personally need and is actually why I upgraded to my 2021 Tahoe Z71 to get them. For me, I guess it's my aviation background as a former pilot and Air Traffic Controller that witnessed many, many improvements over the years from "beacon slashes" to full blown data blocks on our radar screens and from manual to automated hand-offs to other ATC sectors, not to mention all the warning systems (e.g., terrain warning systems, etc.) that evolved. I pay $57.98 a month for OnStar for my 2014 Corvette and 2021 Tahoe. Now that doesn't include a data plan, but I do get all the safety features. I agree that it would be nice to have a 3 year plan come standard to give people a longer chance to make up their mind to continue or not, or reduce to a plan suitable for their needs. My Nav is either Apple or Google Maps, which works fine for me as neither vehicles has a HUD.

Sorry for the rant, but thought I'd offer an "old guy" perspective. Thanks.
Well let me explain why some have an issue with Onstar. Just like our Apple iphones we agree to give up our privacy to get the shiny thing. Onstar is not just a service to you and a convienience or a saftey feature. It also tracks and stores all your information. Law enforcement, private investigators, and insurance investigators go after this info all the time. So maybe you like getting that notification to change your oil, and would you like to make an appointment at your dealer?? When you go on you GMC profile, notice its communicating with your truck, mileage, etc. Think maybe they make money selling your information?? Is it secure.? Some are very trusting of Onstar. Cant imagine why someone would trust a company that needs to make money. In other words they are making you the product. And you agree to it. Onstar is a great easy tool for Law enforcement. The argument of I am not doing anything wrong doesnt work. Its YOUR privacy and info. Its not protected and can be used against you. Yes insurance investigators hook right up to the truck after an accident and download all your info from the blackbox, Onstart is just extra. I have seen Onstar abused many times. Its a choice to get the shiny thing...many dont think about their privacy and info and being the product.
 

972sparky

Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2022
Posts
79
Reaction score
75
In the middle of West Virginia mountains...maybe Banjo Mtn, I broke down. Hit OnStar and got a reply. Something like "Out of service area" or "No connection" or something like that. OnStar is a TOTAL WASTE !!!
There is some places in the WV mountains that you are not even supposed to use a cell phone let alone have service or any other RF device. There are radio telescopes there that they don't want the interference to affect them.
 

Dayzoo

TYF Newbie
Joined
Apr 19, 2022
Posts
16
Reaction score
2
Location
Ontario, Canda
Bigger question to me is what will this do to the resale / 2nd+ owner user who doesn't want to buy into all of that?
They can still have CarPlay, it's just not wireless...

I think this subscription 'thing' is the new future - look at computer software as well - no more purchasing the program - it's all monthly subscriptions now. Certainly not how I'd like things to go, but..... :yucky:
 

EvergreenZ71

Full Access Member
Firefighter EMT/First Responder
Joined
May 29, 2020
Posts
152
Reaction score
117
Location
Washington
They can still have CarPlay, it's just not wireless...

I think this subscription 'thing' is the new future - look at computer software as well - no more purchasing the program - it's all monthly subscriptions now. Certainly not how I'd like things to go, but..... :yucky:
I have a feeling I’ll be taking care of my 2009 & 2010 for a long time …
 

StephenPT

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2022
Posts
1,249
Reaction score
1,263
Location
St. Helens, OR
Did GMC remove the OnStar requirement? When I build and price a Yukon I don’t see the “option” anywhere in the list. It’s also not shown on the summary page at the end of the build? Maybe I’m just not seeing it, but it looks like the requirement has been dropped.
 

mountie

Elite Member
Supporting Member
Joined
May 9, 2018
Posts
7,068
Reaction score
13,809
Location
Wellington, Fl., (formally Kalifornia)
Did GMC remove the OnStar requirement? When I build and price a Yukon I don’t see the “option” anywhere in the list. It’s also not shown on the summary page at the end of the build? Maybe I’m just not seeing it, but it looks like the requirement has been dropped.
Maybe it isn't listed as an "option" like tires or a windshield..... ( maybe thrown in as a base factory install ?) I would contact your dealer rep.
 

WalleyeMikeIII

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2022
Posts
2,753
Reaction score
2,615
Location
Sunny and Snowy Minnesota
Seems it’s now listed as standard equipment. GM
Must have wised up and just bumped the base price abs “included” it vs. itemizing as mandatory option.
 

Stbentoak

Full Access Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2020
Posts
2,241
Reaction score
2,692
If you haven't seen my post in the lounge section, just want to let everybody know that during Hurricane Ian in Fort Myers OnStar was absolutely the only thing functioning as far as Communications goes... there was Zero cell, Zero Internet, zero Towers, nothing... no contact at all. Radio Silence. OnStar was able to answer and Patch calls through to people that needed desperate information. I take back any negative comments I said about them in previous posts. They also were able to send directions to my vehicle as we evacuated to Miami as common routes were not available.
I for one, don't care about a measily $25 a month. That service will stay on for me.
 

zbad55

Full Access Member
Army
Joined
Dec 1, 2017
Posts
365
Reaction score
340
Location
Detroit
They didn't drop it, it will appear on the window sticker and is still required.
 

B-train

Full Access Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2022
Posts
2,706
Reaction score
4,911
I ordered a 22 and tried what I did with my 2007, and 2016, OnStar delete, so neither has it even installed. I wasn't happy I could no longer delete it, I am not a fan of it. The technology gets dated and there are no upgrades. Now that my 22 is a 23, I have to pay for 3 years of it, which I don't want or need.
Agreed. It's just an added profit margin item that allows too much snooping and the ability to remotely control your vehicle.

Had it on 8 vehicles since 2001 and never used it once. It's a waste
 

MSU BullDAWGz

TYF Newbie
Joined
Sep 29, 2022
Posts
23
Reaction score
19
Back in the 60's they added seatbelts. Did YOU ask for them? That added cost to the vehicles. So did safety glass in all the windows. What about radial tires? They were optional but then became mandatory. Did YOU ask for that? I mean come on, they could put a solid front axle back on all 4x4s as that would be cheaper. Just the ride and handling wouldn't be as good. But did YOU ask to pay more for independent front suspension? Cars and truck manufacturers have been doing things like this since Henry Ford said "They can buy a model T in ANY color they want as long as it's BLACK".
And please don't say I'm for OnStar. I'm actually one of those that hates the idea that some cop (not a good one but one with an agenda) or a nerd living in a basement can find and shut off my truck with me in it. Lock the doors etc. So me personally I'd like it removed, but I'm also against seatbelts in some cases (highways-yes, slow off-road no). But I don't see either of them being removed anytime soon.
Would it have been better to just hide it in the cost as a regular feature? Sure, and most wouldn't bat an eye. But instead they didn't and now YOU think you should be able to say what they do. But as I've shown, they do what makes them $$$, what the government demands, and what the majority of customers want. Not what a small minority demand.
That's not to say that if enough people complain it can't change. But hell more should complain about our corrupt government and demand change as that's costing lives and way more than $1600 for 3 years of OnStar.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
137,686
Posts
1,989,603
Members
102,687
Latest member
JohanZ
Back
Top