Why So Many Guests?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

RoadTrip

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2023
Posts
198
Reaction score
411
Location
FL & MN
To the Admins:

This morning I looked snd there were 10 members online and 989 guests!

Are those “guests” bots combing the site for information, or what?

Please explain.
 

Fless

Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Posts
15,344
Reaction score
31,410
Location
Elev 5,280
With the tool I can view, most are "Guests" meaning they're likely non-members or members that are not logged in. There are a few Robots (multiple occurrences and identified as such) like Bing, Yahoo, Applebot, Google AdSense, Facebook, etc., but they're probably only 1 or 2% of the guests.
 

2024 White Tahoe

Full Access Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2024
Posts
285
Reaction score
272
To the Admins:

This morning I looked snd there were 10 members online and 989 guests!

Are those “guests” bots combing the site for information, or what?

Please explain.


Often, as a member, I will connect to the site and scan the latest posts without logging in to the forum. I assume the software indicates I am a guest and not a member?
 

Doubeleive

Wes
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2017
Posts
29,434
Reaction score
45,643
Location
Stockton, Ca.
To the Admins:

This morning I looked snd there were 10 members online and 989 guests!

Are those “guests” bots combing the site for information, or what?

Please explain.
considering anyone can view the site, less than 1k is a drop in the bucket, registration is only required if you intended to post or comment.
just in the time I posted this the guest number changed by over 100
 

Fless

Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Posts
15,344
Reaction score
31,410
Location
Elev 5,280
Often, as a member, I will connect to the site and scan the latest posts without logging in to the forum. I assume the software indicates I am a guest and not a member?

Yes. How would it know it's you if you didn't log in? Not like the software tracks IPs or anything. ;)
 

Venator

Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2025
Posts
49
Reaction score
61
I run a couple of forums, and have seen similar "guest" behaviour in recent months. Increasing from several surfers at a time, which is standard behaviour, to several hundred guests at a time, which is more than the number of members.

They're likely spammers. I'm currently getting hundreds of attempted spam registrations each week, all with different usernames, email domains, and IP addresses. I manually verify every application, so none of them have gotten through.

They're getting smarter, and can even pass the skill-testing questions I've added to the registration pages. However, they don't seem to be able to figure out questions where there's no "set" answer, ie. a personal detail, and usually just enter random characters.

Most of it is from a single organization (or individual), as they always answer one of the questions with the same non-sensical phrase.

I've entered all of the known agent strings for the search-engine bots, scrapers, etc., so those show up as "bots" and not guests.

If you're not seeing spam posts here, it's because the mods are doing a stellar job.
 
OP
OP
RoadTrip

RoadTrip

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2023
Posts
198
Reaction score
411
Location
FL & MN
I run a couple of forums, and have seen similar "guest" behaviour in recent months. Increasing from several surfers at a time, which is standard behaviour, to several hundred guests at a time, which is more than the number of members.

They're likely spammers. I'm currently getting hundreds of attempted spam registrations each week, all with different usernames, email domains, and IP addresses. I manually verify every application, so none of them have gotten through.

They're getting smarter, and can even pass the skill-testing questions I've added to the registration pages. However, they don't seem to be able to figure out questions where there's no "set" answer, ie. a personal detail, and usually just enter random characters.

Most of it is from a single organization (or individual), as they always answer one of the questions with the same non-sensical phrase.

I've entered all of the known agent strings for the search-engine bots, scrapers, etc., so those show up as "bots" and not guests.

If you're not seeing spam posts here, it's because the mods are doing a stellar job.

Thank you for the excellent description and answer!

Best of luck with the forums you manage. May you always manage to stay at least one qualification question ahead of the bots.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
137,694
Posts
1,966,730
Members
102,111
Latest member
johnnyc

Latest posts

Back
Top