This is not something I experienced myself, but from reading a bunch of forums and from threads in this forum, here are some things for you to consider:
1. Take a look at your fuel ventilation system. If the system isn't properly venting, you could have a partial vacuum fighting the pump. I'd especially look at the vent solenoid in the engine compartment. But you should check ALL of the venting system. Have you ever had trouble fully filling the tank?
2. Check your positive wiring, especially between the alternator and the power distribution block (the place where all the relays and fuses live, under the hood). You have not provided any other symptoms, so this is a long shot.
3. Wiggle all your grounds. Something could be loose!
4. Unfortunately, new parts are not all equal. Did you get an AC Delco fuel pump? A lot of us on this forum are skin flints and wouldn't spend a found penny if there were any other way. The recommendations across all forums I've read has been to go with the AC Delco pump. Barring that, there are several, reputable aftermarket vendors that provide performance pumps for out trucks. Unless you are running a modified engine -- or plan to! -- a performance pump is overkill.
Finally, where are you testing the PSI/How are you testing the PSI?
Good luck. Crap like this is annoying. The big stuff will make or break you, but the little stuff destroys sanity!