Transmission Fluid Change Denali XL

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

bottomline2000

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Posts
1,722
Reaction score
987
Location
Dallas, TX
What am I missing here? The trans hit 210-215 a few times and we're already talking about impending failure?

Everybody does know that the "trans hot, idle engine" warning comes on at 265°, right?
And everyone knows Dex6 can go even higher than that for short periods with minimal degradation, right?

I've had my transmission much higher than 215°, it has 190k miles on it, and it still functions/shifts perfectly. I drive it hard, tow really heavy stuff, and generally abuse the hell out of it. Moving 16,000 lbs up towards the Eisenhower Tunnel:
H2EL8bV.jpg


To the OP - your transmission is not on the verge of failure. Do a full flush and keep on trucking. I do a full flush every 50k. YMMV.
Your engine temps are warmer than normal and it seems you just stopped due to the full tank. Have you replaced the water pump in the truck or cooling system flush with 190k miles on the truck? You say you only spent $150 on maintenance so I'm assuming it's still all original.

With that kind of mileage I would have at least replaced the water pump, flushed the cooling system and put a Tru cool 40k trans cooler on it. Even if the truck can survive that kind of abuse why run at those temps if you don't have to?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-T377A using Tapatalk
 

intheburbs

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2017
Posts
774
Reaction score
1,340
Location
SE MI
Your engine temps are warmer than normal and it seems you just stopped due to the full tank. Have you replaced the water pump in the truck or cooling system flush with 190k miles on the truck? You say you only spent $150 on maintenance so I'm assuming it's still all original.

With that kind of mileage I would have at least replaced the water pump, flushed the cooling system and put a Tru cool 40k trans cooler on it. Even if the truck can survive that kind of abuse why run at those temps if you don't have to?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-T377A using Tapatalk

Edit: Read what I typed. I didn't say I've spent $150 on maintenance. I said I've spent $150 on repairs - as in something broke and I had to fix it. I've probably spent at least $1000 alone on fluid changes. At 200k, I'll do all fluids again - trans, transfer, and both axles.

Coolant was done when I bought the truck with 100k miles. I'll probably be doing it again after I roll 200k.

That picture was the absolute extreme case. I took the picture just to capture what I knew was the worst case the truck would ever see. Plus, I just like to freak people out on the internet. :p

You are correct - we had just stopped for gas in Silverthorne, and were making the final push up to the Eisenhower tunnel. Elevation over 11,000 feet, grades as steep as 7%, and I seem to recall I had the accelerator on the floor a lot of the time. At that altitude, the engine is making about 30% less power, so my beastly 6.0 with 350 hp is now wheezing out about 250 horsepower. Add to that my GVW was right at 16,000 lbs, and the truck seemed to be reasonably happy at 4000 RPM in 2nd gear doing 40. I had lots of company, as many semis were going about the same speed, or even slower.

I don't see the point in adding a bigger trans cooler, when I've done that to the truck exactly 3 times climbing the various passes in the Rockies - Eisenhower once, Powder River (9666') twice. 99.9% of the time, the transmission is below 210°. And I flush the transmission religiously every 50k miles. Ditto for the engine - it's actually creepy how the needle never moves off 210° except in the absolute worst cases.

The first time we went to the Rockies, I talked to my friend who is the transmission validation engineer at GM. I expressed my concern about the 230°-240° temperature I saw on the ascent. He actually worked on validating the 6L80/90 transmissions back in 2006. He said "Don't worry about it. We did much worse in validation."

This is the reason I upgraded to a 2500 truck. People wrongly assume that since the 1500 and 2500 Suburbans share the same body, that the 2500 is simply a 1500 that's been "beefed up" a bit. Couldn't be further from the truth. Beneath the body, the two trucks are completely different. Almost zero shared components - completely different frame, engine, transmission, suspension, steering, brakes, springs (torsion front, leaf rear, like GMT800), axles, and wheels. The rear axle in my Suburban is the 10.5" freefloater from American Axle. AA rates the axle to 8600 lbs. My Suburban has an 8600-lb GVWR. Think that's a bit of overkill? The 2500 Suburbans were built for one purpose - towing. And GM did a good job.
 
Last edited:

bottomline2000

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Posts
1,722
Reaction score
987
Location
Dallas, TX
Edit: Read what I typed. I didn't say I've spent $150 on maintenance. I said I've spent $150 on repairs - as in something broke and I had to fix it. I've probably spent at least $1000 alone on fluid changes. At 200k, I'll do all fluids again - trans, transfer, and both axles.

Coolant was done when I bought the truck with 100k miles. I'll probably be doing it again after I roll 200k.

That picture was the absolute extreme case. I took the picture just to capture what I knew was the worst case the truck would ever see. Plus, I just like to freak people out on the internet. [emoji14]

You are correct - we had just stopped for gas in Silverthorne, and were making the final push up to the Eisenhower tunnel. Elevation over 11,000 feet, grades as steep as 7%, and I seem to recall I had the accelerator on the floor a lot of the time. At that altitude, the engine is making about 30% less power, so my beastly 6.0 with 350 hp is now wheezing out about 250 horsepower. Add to that my GVW was right at 16,000 lbs, and the truck seemed to be reasonably happy at 4000 RPM in 2nd gear doing 40. I had lots of company, as many semis were going about the same speed, or even slower.

I don't see the point in adding a bigger trans cooler, when I've done that to the truck exactly 3 times climbing the various passes in the Rockies - Eisenhower once, Powder River (9666') twice. 99.9% of the time, the transmission is below 210°. And I flush the transmission religiously every 50k miles. Ditto for the engine - it's actually creepy how the needle never moves off 210° except in the absolute worst cases.

The first time we went to the Rockies, I talked to my friend who is the transmission validation engineer at GM. I expressed my concern about the 230°-240° temperature I saw on the ascent. He actually worked on validating the 6L80/90 transmissions back in 2006. He said "Don't worry about it. We did much worse in validation."

This is the reason I upgraded to a 2500 truck. People wrongly assume that since the 1500 and 2500 Suburbans share the same body, that the 2500 is simply a 1500 that's been "beefed up" a bit. Couldn't be further from the truth. Beneath the body, the two trucks are completely different. Almost zero shared components - completely different frame, engine, transmission, suspension, steering, brakes, springs (torsion front, leaf rear, like GMT800), axles, and wheels. The rear axle in my Suburban is the 10.5" freefloater from American Axle. AA rates the axle to 8600 lbs. My Suburban has an 8600-lb GVWR. Think that's a bit of overkill? The 2500 Suburbans were built for one purpose - towing. And GM did a good job.
I understand the 2500 series as I have the engine and trans in my Tahoe and i know they have differnet DNA undrneath. I dont tow so i dont need the length or weight of the 2500 series..just the strong drivetrain parts[emoji6] Hey if it works for ya keep on trucking. I was just pointing out what I felt would make things easier because a hot engine is going to make even less power and a cooler trans will better preserve the internal seals and clutches which is what counts no matter how resilient the fluid is to temps. The pic shows trans temps at 241 degrees and engine temos well over 210. Towing at altitude on a grade is about as bad as it gets so thats a good example of extreme duty.

I think the moral of the story is keep the fluids fresh and do religious maintenance...but if you start pushing fluids something is not happy so dig deeper..

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-T377A using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

intheburbs

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2017
Posts
774
Reaction score
1,340
Location
SE MI
I understand the 2500 series as I have the engine and trans in my Tahoe and i know they have differnet DNA undrneath. I dont tow so i dont need the length or weight of the 2500 series..just the strong drivetrain parts[emoji6] Hey if it works for ya keep on trucking. I was just pointing out what I felt would make things easier because a hot engine is going to make even less power and a cooler trans will better preserve the internal seals and clutches which is what counts no matter how resilient the fluid is to temps. Towing at altitude on a grade is about as bad as it gets so thats a good example of extreme duty.

I think the moral of the story is keep the fluids fresh and do religious maintenance...but if you start pushing fluids something is not happy so dig deeper..

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-T377A using Tapatalk

Not quite. I have the LY6 6.0 - iron block and VVT, and I have the 6L90, not the 4L85. Those extra two gears make a big difference.

And I'm a seal guy. That's what I do for a living - I sell seals - orings, gaskets, u-cups, etc. So I'm very much aware of proper care and maintenance of these systems, as I've worked with automotive Tier 1s to design the seals for their subcomponents.
 

bottomline2000

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Posts
1,722
Reaction score
987
Location
Dallas, TX
Not quite. I have the LY6 6.0 - iron block and VVT, and I have the 6L90, not the 4L85. Those extra two gears make a big difference.

And I'm a seal guy. That's what I do for a living - I sell seals - orings, gaskets, u-cups, etc. So I'm very much aware of proper care and maintenance of these systems, as I've worked with automotive Tier 1s to design the seals for their subcomponents.
Understood..I have a gmt800 so I thought it was given my engine trans combo not your same platform. I understand the mechanical advantage also of 6 vs 4 gears and splitting ratios..

Sounds like you got it all under control so enjoy the ride.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk
 

kbuskill

***CAUTION*** I do my own stunts!
Joined
Mar 11, 2017
Posts
5,229
Reaction score
8,115
Location
NE. FL.
Also... just as a side note... the factory coolant temperature gauge is not accurate.

I believe GM designed it to sit in the middle (210°) because that makes "normal" people comfortable to see it in the middle... like the oil pressure and volt meter.

If you look at the temperature of the coolant via a scan tool like the Tech2 or even an OBD2 scanner with Torque Pro you will see that when the temperature gauge is at the normal operating temperature of 210° the ACTUAL temperature is about 190°-192°. So almost 20° cooler than what it shows on the gauge.

I do not know if this is linear or if it changes with temperature but my guess is it probably is linear across the board as I have watched the actual temps while watching the gauge rise and it is pretty consistent.
 

bottomline2000

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Posts
1,722
Reaction score
987
Location
Dallas, TX
Found a list on wiki. Its on older cars? What about 4l85, will that fit without custom work?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM_4L80-E_transmission
It depends on what you consider custom and what you consider older. My 4l85 is from a latter 08-09 cargo van but it was one of the last vehicles to have this transmission. What vehicle do you have and what transmission is currently in your truck? The 80e is slightly longer than a 60 and roughly the same size as a 6l80/90. It's obviously the predecessor to the 6l80 so I'm not sure you would want to do that swap, but they can and mine is modified to double it's holding power with a 1200hp rated custom converter, but I could have used a stock converter. Only my Cross member is custom , but I could have used a modified factory one and of course my computer has a trans segment swap to make it work so what are you running?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-T377A using Tapatalk
 

Meccanoble

Full Access Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2016
Posts
1,166
Reaction score
353
Location
Georgia
I have the 6 speed version that comes in the 2011 Tahoe (6l80e). I was thinking I should be trying to find a 6l90 if it will fit or try to swap certain parts? Or would I be better just beefing up mine? Those were the 2 options I think if/when mine goes. Get a used 6l90 if it will fit and throw it on or rebuild the 6l80. Here are some details I found about the 6l90. It comes in the Camaro ZL1 so it has to be something special. I think we have same tranny in older corvettes. But 6l90 only takes 452 hp max? Must be worthless to the supercharged guys....

http://gmauthority.com/blog/gm/gm-transmissions/myd/

The 6L90 is a heavy-duty version of the 6L80 six-speed automatic, with a strengthened input gearset that has two additional pinion gears (six in total) and a strengthened output gearset that uses wider gears than the 6L80. Its flexibility extends to the clutches, where the 6L90 has one more clutch plate in each clutch than the 6L80 for heavy-duty applications. There is also a 6L90 version without the additional clutch plate to more closely match application requirements, where appropriate.



The 6L90 shares about 75 percent of the parts as the 6L80, although the case of the 6L90 is 35 mm longer than the 6L80 case. The 6L90’s case also accommodates additional fasteners between the transmission and the transfer case for improved driveline noise/vibration performance.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
129,220
Posts
1,812,341
Members
92,321
Latest member
rick3645
Top