Looks like we're in for higher gas prices in the foreseeable future. Does that make the Duramax an even better choice?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

playadude

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2017
Posts
32
Reaction score
19
I bought the Duramax Tahoe because I loved the motor. I didn't really care about gas milage.

Now that I own it, I love the gas milage (and massive range on a full tank).

Big gas prices have to make more demand for the Diesel.

What do you guys think?
 

Bill 1960

Testing the Limits
Joined
Dec 17, 2020
Posts
1,480
Reaction score
2,866
I like diesels, and if I will likely buy another one soon. That said, I don’t see fuel cost being much of a motivator for buyers of this vehicle class.

I had a little rental this week that was giving 40mpg at 80 mph. But I would never buy that car.

Inflation probably will -or maybe already is?- pushing some buyers down market.

I guess what I’m trying to say is fuel cost might move some drivers away from a gas guzzler, but a cost sensitive buyer probably won’t take the diesel route.
 

TollKeeper

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Posts
3,581
Reaction score
7,520
Location
Brighton, CO
I think certain select diesels are going to be the way to go.. But the diesel selections are confusing.

GM 2.8 I4 diesel available in the Canyon/Colorado get worse fuel mileage than the 3.0 diesel I6. Is this transmission related, as the Canyon only has a 6 speed, vs the 10 in the Sierra/Silvy? or are there other variables involved?

Further, the pricing has to make sense. The 3.0 I6 is only 900-1000 bucks more over the 5.3, and 2400 more than the 2.7 gas, and 1400 CHEAPER than the 6.2 V8. But its 4800 more in the Canyon. That doesnt make sense..

Next you are fighting the stigma of black soot belching diesels of yesteryear, and the mindsets of Diesel=Bad.

GM has a bigger hill to climb.. The 6.2 left a bad taste in everyones mouth. The 6.5 was no better. The very rare 4.3 diesel is Meh at best. And should I even mention the gas converted 350 diesel.. Boat anchor anyone?

GM hit it out of the park with the LBZ in 2006-07.. But then came the EPA shaking their little finger.

So the issue evolves, for GM anyways, how to entice your average joe into buying a diesel. You dont have to look further than the 2014-15 Chevy Cruze Diesel, which bombed something fierce.
 

OR VietVet

GMT800 2005 Tahoe Z71
Navy Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2014
Posts
23,775
Reaction score
44,301
Location
Willamette Valley
Back when the war in Afghanistan started, I bought my first Duramax, think it was an 2003 or 2004, and the war had been going on for a little while and because of all the diesel fuel usage overseas, the price of diesel was higher than premium fuel. Plus, now some states, like Oregon is trying to shut down diesel fuel by 2006 to 2008.
 
OP
OP
playadude

playadude

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2017
Posts
32
Reaction score
19
I think certain select diesels are going to be the way to go.. But the diesel selections are confusing.

GM 2.8 I4 diesel available in the Canyon/Colorado get worse fuel mileage than the 3.0 diesel I6. Is this transmission related, as the Canyon only has a 6 speed, vs the 10 in the Sierra/Silvy? or are there other variables involved?

Further, the pricing has to make sense. The 3.0 I6 is only 900-1000 bucks more over the 5.3, and 2400 more than the 2.7 gas, and 1400 CHEAPER than the 6.2 V8. But its 4800 more in the Canyon. That doesnt make sense..

Next you are fighting the stigma of black soot belching diesels of yesteryear, and the mindsets of Diesel=Bad.

GM has a bigger hill to climb.. The 6.2 left a bad taste in everyones mouth. The 6.5 was no better. The very rare 4.3 diesel is Meh at best. And should I even mention the gas converted 350 diesel.. Boat anchor anyone?

GM hit it out of the park with the LBZ in 2006-07.. But then came the EPA shaking their little finger.

So the issue evolves, for GM anyways, how to entice your average joe into buying a diesel. You dont have to look further than the 2014-15 Chevy Cruze Diesel, which bombed something fierce.
That's an amazing response, thank you.
 
OP
OP
playadude

playadude

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2017
Posts
32
Reaction score
19
Just read all of the responses. I always wondered why GM still makes the 5.3 which is 30 year old technology (early 90's).

The answer is, because people buy them.

I bet after R&D, a 3.0 Duramax total cost for GM (including the decade of R&D) is 4 times (or more) than the 5.3.

And, they charge $900 more for it.

Actually, what is the in-house cost for a 5.3 and a 3.0 Diesel? That would be interesting to know.
 

TollKeeper

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Posts
3,581
Reaction score
7,520
Location
Brighton, CO
Continuing..

Adding more insult to injury, the diesel, for all intensive purposes, should be a cheaper engine to make... Well that is, at least, until the EPA gets involved. True, back in the day, some diesels (Ford 7.3 PowerStroke comes to mind) was the cats meow. Break downs were minimal if maintained correctly, and repairs were expensive.

Now we are 3-6 gens later from that diesel. Diesels are expensive, no matter what you do.. DEF, EGR, SCR, DOZER, Injectors, 30 computers, and the list goes on.

Diesel Fuel, a Bi-Product of gasoline, should be insanely cheap. Again, the EPA comes in shaking its finger, and demanding more, out of what came down to a near free product from the gasoline producer. Now it costs as much to make, as gasoline, because of further refining processes.

Dodge doesnt make their own diesel (Cummins, or EcoDiesel/Nissan?).
Ford doesnt make their own diesel (International/VW)
GM technically doesnt make their own diesel (Isuzu)

So because the engines come from a third party, the engine becomes more expensive.

Some manufactures have completely staved off from the diesel (at least in the US), to streamline, and for profit (Volvo).

And then you have to add in the Electric Future, the complete, and utter, --LIE-- given to us about its "greeness", and The relative cheapness of the vehicles (Ford Maverick, at 40ehMPG) at 26k.

When you add all these obstacles that diesel faces, its really hard for it to make sense.

The tuner market is going to hate these new "high stress" diesels, as every available HP and TQ is likely already being squeezed out of it. Leaving very little for the tuners.
 
Last edited:

Stbentoak

Full Access Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2020
Posts
2,255
Reaction score
2,732
Now we are 3-6 gens later from that diesel. Diesels are expensive, no matter what you do.. DEF, EGR, SCR, DOZER, Injectors, 30 computers, and the list goes on.

Diesel Fuel, a Bi-Product of gasoline, should be insanely cheap. Again, the EPA comes in shaking its finger, and demanding more, out of what came down to a near free product from the gasoline producer. Now it costs as much to make, as gasoline, because of further refining processes.

Dodge doesnt make their own diesel (Cummins, or EcoDiesel/Nissan?).
Ford doesnt make their own diesel (International/VW)
GM technically doesnt make their own diesel (Isuzu)

So because the engines come from a third party, the engine becomes more expensive.
You say that diesels are expensive, but mine was a $1500 discount on the Denali I bought. It is evidencing to be the very best choice for this vehicle. My 17 yr old Cummins I have done nothing to except change oil and fuel filters, in 17 years. Probably one of the most cost efficient vehicles I have ever owned.
You say diesel should be cheaper, and I will agree with you that it is near the bottom of the barrel in the fuel separation process….
but they seemEd to figure it out that they could get more for it, refine it a little more and put the price up near gasoline. Not much we can do about that, but it’s still a superior fuel mileage wise.
While many manufacturers don’t make their engines, that’s not necessarily a bad thing as these other manufacturers absolutely specialize in diesel light and medium duty engines and are engineering years ahead in their expertise. Although the new LM2 in our SUV’s is a 100% GM product. I’m not really worried about that because we are hardly stressing these engines just doing our daily business.
Although they won’t be in vehicles, diesels will still be around many many years into the future. Of the many years I have had them, they have served me well and paid me back in spades in fuel economy…. Not to mention when people get their fuzz up over an economic crisis, or there is a hurricane in the area and stations are empty, I buzz right by the lines, hit the diesel pump and I’m on my way while the other people are in lines around the block…
Sadly, I could be driving my last one right now….
 

TollKeeper

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Posts
3,581
Reaction score
7,520
Location
Brighton, CO
You say that diesels are expensive, but mine was a $1500 discount on the Denali I bought. It is evidencing to be the very best choice for this vehicle. My 17 yr old Cummins I have done nothing to except change oil and fuel filters, in 17 years. Probably one of the most cost efficient vehicles I have ever owned.
A 2003 Dodge Cummins? So it still had the venerable 5.9? Another one of the great diesel engines. We have 4 of those engines in our fleet.. We are trying to sell 3 of them.

My reference to "expensive" was to when they do break, they are expensive, I forgot a couple words there, my bad.

Seeing GM's history with diesel on light duty platforms, I forsee this being one of those 1-4 year productions, and they will axe it for cost savings.

As I said in this thread.. (and you replied to)

The BM is a fantastic engine, designed exactly at the right time.. Just a matter of convincing the average Joe of that.
 

FrankU

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2013
Posts
705
Reaction score
846
Location
Babylon New York
Diesel fuel expensive ? Check out the federal excise tax on diesel compare to gasoline.
No one is paying attention to whats going on in NK and Iran. I see much higher fuel prices on the horizon.
 

OR VietVet

GMT800 2005 Tahoe Z71
Navy Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2014
Posts
23,775
Reaction score
44,301
Location
Willamette Valley
My Chevron, 2 blocks down has fuel/gas at $3.76, $3.86 and $4.09. They don't have diesel there.

In Warrensburg, Mo., where I will be moving to within the year, Phillips 66 $2.71, 3.11, 3.36 and 2.89 diesel.
 
Last edited:

TollKeeper

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Posts
3,581
Reaction score
7,520
Location
Brighton, CO
3.37 Reg E15
3.67 Mid E15
3.97 Pre E15
3.77 Pre E-Free
3.38 Diesel
2.59 E85

And this is why I am considering modifying my Esky to E-85, or selling it, and getting a something else..
 
Last edited:

Stbentoak

Full Access Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2020
Posts
2,255
Reaction score
2,732
I agree…. We are only one good world event away from 5$ gas. Diesel will rise also, but I’ll be happier knowing I’m going further on it…
Diesel fuel expensive ? Check out the federal excise tax on diesel compare to gasoline.
No one is paying attention to whats going on in NK and Iran. I see much higher fuel prices on the horizon.
 

TollKeeper

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Posts
3,581
Reaction score
7,520
Location
Brighton, CO

Attachments

  • 500px-Fuel_taxes_in_the_united_states.png
    500px-Fuel_taxes_in_the_united_states.png
    97.3 KB · Views: 31

steiny93

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2021
Posts
455
Reaction score
402
I bought the Duramax Tahoe because I loved the motor. I didn't really care about gas milage.

Now that I own it, I love the gas milage (and massive range on a full tank).

Big gas prices have to make more demand for the Diesel.

What do you guys think?
If fuel (gas and diesel) prices go up massively (like they did a few years ago). Vehicles that use alot of fuel with be camping on the dealership lots (just like they did a few years ago). When that happens the variants which are fuel efficient will sell better (like how the ecoDiesels did).

Personally, I wouldn't have bought a 2021 if the diesel wasn't an option.
 

Miami-Dade

Staff member
Moderator Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2016
Posts
4,216
Reaction score
5,564
Diesel fuel expensive ? Check out the federal excise tax on diesel compare to gasoline.
No one is paying attention to whats going on in NK and Iran. I see much higher fuel prices on the horizon.
Just a reminder no politics of any kind or this thread will be locked.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
137,809
Posts
1,992,720
Members
102,794
Latest member
Drewphil
Back
Top