Frankly, I disagree you need to be a clairvoyant to offer likely accurate suggestions to fix an engine that won't turn over. Am I jumping to conclusions that it isn't turning over when he tries to start it and it won't start? Sure.
But if someone comes on and says his engine won't start and he has replaced the battery, had the starter tested and replaced the ignition key cylinder, while it is a jump to think his starter likely wasn't turning, it isn't too much of a leap. The list of things it might be, given he has a new battery and has had his starter tested good, well, isn't that long a list and most of the likely ones have been mentioned.
But then, maybe his engine does turn over when it won't start. If he comes back at all and we find out that is the case, it will likely be a longer and more rewarding thread for all who like to solve puzzles.
Come to think of it, I might be jumping to conclusions it was a he. I mean, just because someone picks a handle of James, doesn't make them a he...