87 or 91 octane gas

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

mikez71

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2023
Posts
3,466
Reaction score
4,318
Here's the only difference between '08 yukon 6.2 and '08 escalade 6.2.
I could not find any difference between yukon/escalade files in either '10 or '13.
08yuk-08esc.png
 

swathdiver

Full Access Member
Joined
May 18, 2017
Posts
21,382
Reaction score
30,471
Location
Treasure Coast, Florida
I’d like to see data from this decade that proves engines run “cleaner and cooler” on higher octane fuel. They also only started certifying top tier fuel in 2004. So your 40 year old anecdotal evidence may need to be revised. But if you want to live on 80’s information you can do that.

I’d also argue that since you care enough about your engines to run 91 octane you also maintain them pretty well. I’d wonder if all your engines would still be running just fine if the only variable you changed was octane?

I think we can both agree that running top tier certified fuel is the way to go though, even if we can’t agree on octane.

Also, yeah GM recommends premium. It doesn’t require premium. I have a Toyota with a 2ZZ-GE engine that has a 13.5 to 1 compression ratio. That REQUIRES premium.
Well before "Top Tier", only the high octane offerings had the premium additives. If I drove any vehicle for a length of time I would compare gas mileage using low octane and high octane gas, especially when racing. Still do it today, though it's far more detailed in Excel. If you want to see a dramatic example of your vehicle running cleaner and cooler with a more smooth idle, run a tank or two of 100-104 octane unleaded in it from Sunoco. You can do the same with E85, it takes about 5 full tanks for the computer to fully adjust to it.

Down here in Florida this is what happens when a man runs 87 in his high compression Gen IV 6.2 engine. Every time he takes off from a traffic light his engine the engine pings and timing is retarded. When he goes to pass a slowpoke, the engine pings or knocks and timing is reduced. This is not always audible as these modern vehicles are so well insulated but it can be seen and measured with the right scan tool. Now, multiply that hundreds of times for one trip, thousands of times a week for a hundred thousand miles and the piston rings usually give up first, followed by a cracked piston or two. Plenty of men have documented this on YouTube such as IDoCars and CrazedPerformanceRepair.

I reckon that if the engine is babied and or runs in a cooler climate and or a higher altitude this knocking and pinging will be less.

It doesn't make sense to me to spend hard earned money on a premium vehicle and then cheap out on operating costs. Decades of driving has taught me that good maintenance makes for a very reliable vehicle.

From my 2013 GMC Sierra Owner's Manual:

1786114462364.png


As for me and my house, our engines are indeed fed a steady diet of Top Tier fuels or run on E85. Chevron and Sunoco are our preferred stations but I have run quite a bit of Shell 93 as of late in an attempt to prove one of my previous assertions wrong, maybe.

I believe those who run low octane fuels for well over 100K miles without consequence are the exceptions to the rule. Again, this belief does not apply to direct injected engines. Thanks Gary! @Miami-Dade
 

j91z28d1

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2022
Posts
4,767
Reaction score
6,057
Here's the only difference between '08 yukon 6.2 and '08 escalade 6.2.
I could not find any difference between yukon/escalade files in either '10 or '13.
View attachment 490916


interesting.. 9deg of timing up top is a lot on a ls. I'm a bit surprised

might be down to driving style. if you just drive around town under 3k all the time. it doesn't hurt anything but a more aggressive driver has issues.


also there's a tons of timing modifiers maps and how aggressive it pulls timing out and how slower it ramps back in
 

Marky Dissod

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2023
Posts
4,589
Reaction score
6,680
Location
(718)-
Here's the only difference between '08 yukon 6.2L and '08 escalade 6.2L.
I could not find any difference between yukon/escalade files in either '10 or '13.
08yuk-08esc-png.png

So the '07 & '08 Denali L92s retard spark timing @ 5000RpM (ecm interpolates tables) IFF WOT fueling is in effect?
Although I've difficulty believing that this is the ONLY difference, that difference alone could be worth about 20 horses.

Also, another good reason for a tune: GM cheated Denali L92s of 20 horsepower.
 

Joseph Garcia

Elite Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2018
Posts
10,925
Reaction score
16,022
View attachment 490948
So the '07 & '08 Denali L92s retard spark timing @ 5000RpM (ecm interpolates tables) IFF WOT fueling is in effect?
Although I've difficulty believing that this is the ONLY difference, that difference alone could be worth about 20 horses.

Also, another good reason for a tune: GM cheated Denali L92s of 20 horsepower.
Exactly.
 
OP
OP
Nagloc68

Nagloc68

TYF Newbie
Joined
Jul 12, 2026
Posts
20
Reaction score
28
I’m the OP and I am glad I started this thread. Factual responses, real data, and only a little bit of aggro! I’ve learned a ton about gas. Also, I’m that GMC owner described above, wanted something nicer to replace my Suburban! Used mostly Costco TopTier 87 gas its whole life. Years ago I reaserched top Tier and was surprised it was a real thing, not a marketing gimmick. when I am traveling I actually search for Top Tier stations to fill up. I now believe that Costco must have good quality gas given my results. Cooler climate in chicago, easy driving, and well maintained. What can I say, I get 18mpg on highway and have averaged 12.8mpg over its life.
Thanks!
 

Miami-Dade

Staff member
Moderator Supporting Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2016
Posts
4,274
Reaction score
5,658
I’m the OP and I am glad I started this thread. Factual responses, real data, and only a little bit of aggro! I’ve learned a ton about gas. Also, I’m that GMC owner described above, wanted something nicer to replace my Suburban! Used mostly Costco TopTier 87 gas its whole life. Years ago I reaserched top Tier and was surprised it was a real thing, not a marketing gimmick. when I am traveling I actually search for Top Tier stations to fill up. I now believe that Costco must have good quality gas given my results. Cooler climate in chicago, easy driving, and well maintained. What can I say, I get 18mpg on highway and have averaged 12.8mpg over its life.
Thanks!
Been using Costco fuel for years in my 5.3 Tahoe. The only other fuel I use is Exxon-Mobil. I only use 87 Regular.
 

ftwflh

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2019
Posts
34
Reaction score
17
Location
Crossville,IL
I searched the forum and couldn’t find a related thread. If there is one, feel free to point me to it.

Original Owner of a 2013 Yukon xl Denali with 191k. Original car, well maintained but stock, original tune so maintains the V8/V4 feature. We have used 87 octane its whole life. Have been reading a bit and have interpreted some comments suggest 91 octane is preferred. But it has always been about $1 more a gallon which is why we used 87. Most of its gas has been purchased at our local Costco which is top tier. 91 is currently $5.23 at Costco!

Engine drives strong and hasn’t caused any concerns. Much of my miles are highway miles. My question is at 191k miles is there any reason to change the octane of gas I use?
Thanks
If you has a 5.3 the engine compression is 9.3:1 and you are very safe running 87
 

Marky Dissod

Full Access Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2023
Posts
4,589
Reaction score
6,680
Location
(718)-
If you has a 5.3L the static compression ratio is 9.3:1 and you are very safe running 87
WTF?
L33, 10.0:1. Every other 5.3L V8 has an scr of 9.9:1, 9.6:1, or 9.5:1 til 2014.

For the record:
'07-'08 6.2L L92, with 10.5:1 scr, rated 380 peak horsepower on 87 octane for non-Cadillacs / 400 peak horsepower on 91 octane for Cadillacs.
'07-'09 6.0L L76 & '11-'17 L77, with 10.4:1 scr, were rated 360 peak horsepower on 87 octane.

Left out the LFA/LZ1 (10.7:1) & the L99 (10.4:1) intentionally ...
Point being, the GM OE tune or the aftermarket tune and the cam chosen, are more responsible for being able to tolerate 87 octane, than static compression.

To cover both sides of the argument:
just because you 'can' use 87 octane, does not mean you SHOULD, especially if the engine/vehicle is working or playing hard.
No matter how good 87 octane can be, 91 is just plain better - hopefully the financial math works out for you.
Gasoline is cheaper than a replacement engine, so is an 87 octane tune.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
138,751
Posts
2,016,129
Members
102,243
Latest member
Mariam26A
Back
Top