Tahoe vs Tacoma

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

TNJYOUNG

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Posts
57
Reaction score
54
Good morning everyone,

I have all but finished the deal where I am trading in my 2016 SR5 Tacoma Double Cab 4X4 (50k miles) in for a 2013 4x4 Chevrolet Tahoe LT (85k miles).

I bought the Tacoma new and had wanted one since my dad sold Toyota trucks in the late 1980s. But once I got it, other than tons of compliments, I was under-impressed. Plus, I am 6 foot tall and I always felt a bit awkward in the Tacoma.

I like cars that will last and from my research the 2013 was relatively problem free and the Tahoe series, in general, seems to have a good reputation. I am excited and nervous about my decision and would love to hear your thoughts. The last v8 that I had was a 2006 Nissan Titan and my wife and I have missed the room and the power ever since.

Cheers,
Jason
 

camaroz2887

Member
Joined
May 16, 2018
Posts
82
Reaction score
60
Location
Nj
How ya doin tnjyoung,
While I can’t specifically about a Toyota product. Which seems to be very nice vehicles from my experience. I did just make the swap from a small v6 ranger and have the same height problem.

To be honest I was amazed by the Tahoe. 2 more cylinders plus close to twice the displacement of my old 3.slow, and my gas mileage went up! You’ll get plenty of room in every direction, but you WILL at some point miss havin the truck bed lol.

The one main drawback on these trucks personally would be the dod/afm (displacement on demand and active fuel management. Mainly the lifters that are spring loaded for closing off 4 cylinders during v4 operation. Check into it and see if it’s something you can and are ready to deal with.

By the way just assuming from the name, you from NJ too?
 
OP
OP
TNJYOUNG

TNJYOUNG

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Posts
57
Reaction score
54
How ya doin tnjyoung,
While I can’t specifically about a Toyota product. Which seems to be very nice vehicles from my experience. I did just make the swap from a small v6 ranger and have the same height problem.

To be honest I was amazed by the Tahoe. 2 more cylinders plus close to twice the displacement of my old 3.slow, and my gas mileage went up! You’ll get plenty of room in every direction, but you WILL at some point miss havin the truck bed lol.

The one main drawback on these trucks personally would be the dod/afm (displacement on demand and active fuel management. Mainly the lifters that are spring loaded for closing off 4 cylinders during v4 operation. Check into it and see if it’s something you can and are ready to deal with.

By the way just assuming from the name, you from NJ too?

Oops, I hit "save changes" a little too quickly.

1. Thank you for the nice, concise, summary.
2. It is too late thinking about it, I already traded.
3. I am from Tennessee TN for Tennessee :)
4. I am sure I will miss the truck bed. It is a nice thing to just throw odd-shaped items into.
5. I cannot wait for the improvement in comfort. My truck had gotten a bit cramped for the family on vacations and travel.
6. I did think it would have more power, but I decided to buy it nonetheless. (maybe the 6.2 has the power that I was expecting in the 5.3?)

Kind regards,
Jason
 

adventurenali92

Full Access Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2015
Posts
7,737
Reaction score
9,212
Location
Big Bear Lake, ca
I’m the standard wheel base tahoe, the 5.3 V8 has plenty of power. And if you’re not going to be towing anything especially large than the extra power that the bigger motors offer isn’t really necessary. There are a lot of pros to having a truck bed, but what if that odd shaped item you or in there can’t get wet and it suddenly starts raining on the way home?! That’s where the tahoe comes in pretty handy! My 2006 xl Denali is my second SUV after having a dodge Dakota, and I haven’t run into a situation yet where I’m like I need a truck for this. Not once. The GM SUVs are quite capable.
 

Fischer

TYF Newbie
Joined
Sep 12, 2017
Posts
10
Reaction score
13
I have an 03 Suburban and it's just me and my dog Charlie I bought it from dear friend of mine who ordered it new it's a Z71. I have the back seats out and the captains chairs folded down so Charlie can have all the room that he wants. I've got the 5.3 and been on the road for thousands of miles and absolutely love it if you're looking for great gas mileage it's probably not the truck but if you're looking for comfort and a cruiser and durability and longevity you made the right decision may God be with you and keep you safe as well as your family good luck
 
OP
OP
TNJYOUNG

TNJYOUNG

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Posts
57
Reaction score
54
I have an 03 Suburban and it's just me and my dog Charlie I bought it from dear friend of mine who ordered it new it's a Z71. I have the back seats out and the captains chairs folded down so Charlie can have all the room that he wants. I've got the 5.3 and been on the road for thousands of miles and absolutely love it if you're looking for great gas mileage it's probably not the truck but if you're looking for comfort and a cruiser and durability and longevity you made the right decision may God be with you and keep you safe as well as your family good luck
I definitely did not buy for gas Mileage. Everything else is exactly what I was hoping to hear. Hope you and Charlie are doing well!
 

Ed 1942

TYF Newbie
Joined
Jun 11, 2018
Posts
3
Reaction score
7
Here's my "Make America Great Again" reply. The big three make the best trucks and SUV's in the world. For a while foreign competitors were making more economical 4 and 6 cylinder (especially trucks). They sold big. Today, these same people want more power and opt for the V8. If you look at the mileage between foreign and domestic there may be 1 or 2 mpg difference. Here's my RANT: If you're one of those that agreed that corporations that went off-shore were un-American, then what are you when you go off-shore for your car/truck thereby sending any profit to another economy rather than the USA?
 

08HoeCD

Full Access Member
Joined
May 6, 2016
Posts
2,052
Reaction score
1,934
NNBS Tahoes are great. Very comfortable, easy to drive & park, lots of room and lots of features. (My LT3 has more features than any car I've ever owned, and it took me almost 6 months to discover & use all of them. lol) Fuel economy sucks, but if you know that going in it's fine, and regardless it's a small price to pay for all that you get overall.
 
OP
OP
TNJYOUNG

TNJYOUNG

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2018
Posts
57
Reaction score
54
Here's my "Make America Great Again" reply. The big three make the best trucks and SUV's in the world. For a while foreign competitors were making more economical 4 and 6 cylinder (especially trucks). They sold big. Today, these same people want more power and opt for the V8. If you look at the mileage between foreign and domestic there may be 1 or 2 mpg difference. Here's my RANT: If you're one of those that agreed that corporations that went off-shore were un-American, then what are you when you go off-shore for your car/truck thereby sending any profit to another economy rather than the USA?
Ed,
I held off on posting a reply until I could get to my laptop, as I knew my reply could get lengthy (something I loathe doing over my phone).

To address your comments/concerns:

When I was young (I am in my mid 40's), I grew up with a father that owned only domestic automobiles. In the 1960s he had Chevelles, Impalas, and Malibus and in the 70s he had Monte Carlos, Z28s, and Novas. In the 1980s he moved into Cadillacs, Caprices, Lincolns, and GM trucks. In the 1990s he moved into Ford Tauruses, F-150s, and ElDorados. He passed away in 2006. He also sold new Lincolns, GM Trucks, Toyotas, VWs, and a host of used cars.

During my time as a youngster, I recall domestic vehicles "crapping out" at or about 100k miles, while I witnessed Hondas, Toyotas, and Datsuns (Nissans) getting 150k-250k miles. When I was in high school there were basically 3 or 4 vehicles that everyone wanted: Honda Preludes, Nissan 240sx, Honda Accords, Mustang GTs, and Toyota pickups. As you can see, 4/5 of these were Japanese. I remember the "vacuum tight" sound of a Japanese car door closing. Meanwhile, GM, Dodge, and Ford made cars like Berettas, Grand Prixs, Camaros, Saturns, Tempos, Escorts, and underpowered Dodge Stealths--most of which had a bumper that seemed to wrap all the way around the car (ugh, sigh, blah). In addition the radios, a/c controls, instrument clusters, etc. felt cheap, gray, and had oversized, under detailed knobs and buttons. These were the cars that seemed to overheat, smoke, make funny noises, have heavy doors, loose fittings, slipping transmissions, and crap out at 100k. At least that was my mindset. BMWs, VWs, Porsche, etc. were sort of the eclectic cars--nice, but they varied in quality and reliability.

With this experience and mindset, I started my adult life with the purchase of my first new vehicle in 1994 with a Toyota pickup, then a Nissan Altima, then a Nissan Pickup, then a Nissan Titan, then Honda Accord after Honda Accord, then Honda Civic, then Toyota Tacoma, etc.

I have always experienced good reliability, good fuel economy, easy parking, good resale value, etc.

In the meantime, GM and Ford seemed to have changed the game, in silent, and in the background to my generation. Time and time again I was hearing of F150s, Silverados, Tahoes, Suburbans, Expeditions, etc. going to 200k plus. In addition, they did it with V8 power and with American ingenuity.

I am very patriotic and over the years, as I have aged, I have become more so. As I have voted, worked, fed and raised children, etc. I have developed a new world view. I now see that the profits from all of my Japanese purchases went overseas and made Honda, Toyota, and Nissan a little richer. I also see that at the same time my actions, and many other like them, directly took jobs away from Americans. I hate that.

Now, I still look for quality, design, and reliability first. Next--> I have recently been, and will continue to, look for things made in the USA.

I had always wanted a Tacoma (or the like) since 1988 or so. When I finally had the financial means, I bought one. I must say that I was never truly happy with it, although I faked it for a while due to pride. It was simply underwhelming. The shifting was wonky, it had rattles, wasn't very comfortable, and the power was lacking. The pipe dream of the well-tuned, sewing-machine-like, long-lasting, well made, fantasy Japanese automobile took a big hit in my mind with that Truck. My wife still drives a Honda Accord with zero problems, but I wanted to try something new so I bit the bullet and ended up with the Tahoe.

So far I am absolutely loving it.

Cheers~
 
Last edited:

swathdiver

Full Access Member
Joined
May 18, 2017
Posts
21,322
Reaction score
30,319
Location
Treasure Coast, Florida
So what is 2015-->forward? NNNBS? New, New, New Body Style? :)

K2

Sick in bed, I was watching old MotorWeek shows on youtube and remembering all the great Detroit Iron from the 1970s and 1980s that I grew up with. We drove *** cars too, and were nearly killed in them all. Every one of them was in a terrible accident that left each of us with life long injuries. My father still likes those little cars but not me, I was a BOPC guy for those who remember the jargon, now, just GMC and Pontiac in my stable.
 
Last edited:

intheburbs

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2017
Posts
952
Reaction score
1,922
Location
SE MI
2000-2006 - GMT800 (NBS)
2007-2013 - GMT900 (NNBS)
2014+ - K2XX

I remember, even relatively recently, I had a 2003 Mercury Sable as my company car. When I got rid of it with 75k miles, the transmission was already starting to go out.

But trucks nowadays - I've had good luck with them. My buddy now owns my 2001 Suburban. While the body is rusting away, it has 250k on the original engine and transmission.

My 2008 Suburban has been the best vehicle I've ever owned. Bought it with 100k miles in 2013. I beat the ever-living snot out of it - towing heavy, drive it like I stole it, etc - and it's been flawlessly reliable. I tow an 8600-lb trailer into the Rockies, have had the transmission temp as high as 241°, and removed the speed governor with the tune and have had it up to 120 MPH indicated. It has 180k miles, everything is original, and I haven't even had to replace the brake pads yet. It's garaged and there's not a spot of rust anywhere on the body, despite living its entire life in Indiana and Michigan.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
138,118
Posts
1,999,611
Members
103,041
Latest member
vtxtexan

Latest posts

Back
Top