This guy is really scientific and detailed. Good video.
Cliff notes
0w20 won't make your engine blow up/seize or malfunction if you continue to use it and keep it changed often...aka don't get lazy or cute with long oil change intervals.
0w20 and all other ultra low viscosity oils are designed to improve fuel consumption in a
very specific drive cycle designated by SAE (for EPA).
Downside is reduced safety factor in oil film thickness.
Upside is statistically validated improvement in fuel economy.
0w40 is good because it has exceptional HTHS capability. 0w40 has 3.5-3.6 HTHS viscosity (cSt)
HTHS is a worst case scenario for what a bearing "sees".
2.3 -2.6 is minimum HTHS by SAE...0w20 operates right at 2.6 cSt. Right at the minimum.
Therefore not much safety factor.
Stribeck curve shows the tribological regimes for lubrication: boundary, mixed, and hydrodynamic
All "0" oils will have the same boundary lubrication. And the mixed lubrication will be similar. The separation happens with hydrodynamic lubrication.
The stribeck factor of speed x viscosity/load is from Sommerfeld formula. In other words, Sommerfeld picks up where Stribeck leaves off.
My take from the video and current recall information:
0W40 is recommended because GM has found a defect in manufacturing that is upsetting the bearing clearances where by 0w20 can't carry the load effectively. This is likely a reduced clearance scenario: crank taper, rod concentricity, bearing crush issue from rod caps being slightly off spec.
This creates a hot spot such that 0w20 film thickness drops to a point that looks like a huge increase in eccentricity ratio in Sommerfeld.
To counteract this, a higher viscosity oil is used.
The new replacement engines and the 2025's are spec'd with 0w20.