ok, let's try something really simple, presuming you have a electrical meter of some sort and you have mastered the skill of pulling a yukon headlight out, then check the 3 wires on the headlight power harness and find the ground, 1 is a ground, 1 is the low beam power and 1 is the high beam power. once you have determined the ground wire leave the one headlight disconnected and attach a piece of wire to the ground post on the headlight harness that is disconnected and ground it to the frame (anywhere close by is fine, loosen a bolt and stick the wire under the bolt and tighten it back down) then go see if the one attached headlight works properly (i.e shuts off like it should) if it does then easy fix just patch a ground wire to the headlight harness it wont hurt anything and will provide the ground that is no longer working stock. it doesn't matter which headlight you do this to because they are on the same harness. try that and report back.