Marky Dissod
Full Access Member
It's not that GM are not permitted, just read the owner's manual.GM probably isn't allowed to tell us to all run in tow/haul
It'll never be encouraged though, kinda like jury nullification.
Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.
It's not that GM are not permitted, just read the owner's manual.GM probably isn't allowed to tell us to all run in tow/haul
All 2018-2020 SUVs with the 6.2l L86 had Gen 1 10L80 transmissions. I have one and it has the noisy straight pump gears in lieu of the newer helical gears. These Gen 1 transmissions are essentially the same as the Ford 10R80's except tor the wiring and programming. Starting in 2021, the SUVs got the L87 with the Gen 2 10L80 with a totally different valve body from the Gen 1. On another note, do you think you may have more favorable bearing load if the DFM was turned on. If the DFM is turned off with a disabler, the existing trans tune may complicate things and not play well with engine load.What I can saw with pretty good certainty is 2009-2010 with the GM bankruptcy along with the mad dash to electrify pre COVID GM lost/go rid of a lot of their ICE Powertrain staff. So a lot of institutional knowledge and experience was lost. Then understand that everyone was asked to do more with less staff, so many things did not get the attention they deserved.
I have contacts in the industry, used to work for GM and know the ins and outs of how they operate and have plenty of hands on experience. Additionally I am working through the "system" at the moment with my specific problem, my problem is not really much different from thousands of other L87 owners, many owners have had engines seize and replaced, many are just ticking time bombs waiting to seize. My problem was not supposed to happen, and I personally did a lot of things to counter any possible problems.
How GM has let this go on for so long and not come to some conclusion as what to do to correct these problems is insane. 3 internal investigations inside GM with not identifying any problem and implanting any corrective action. This just blows my mind, did they not see the problems, or did they decide to ignore them. Either what it is really bad. You would think that GM would have implemented improvements to reduce or stop the high number of failures and they would have made sure Reman engines would live a long healthy life. Maybe the Lawyers told GM not to implement changes because if they did, then they would be considered guilty for the pre-change production. But I just cannot see this as the case.
I am effectively laying down on the train tracks trying to stop the train and force the system to look at this in detail. But the Railroad is big organization and they may choose to throttle up and keep going? The people in the know may not want to see what I have to offer. At the end of the day I hope what I am doing will benefit both my case and every L87 owner, maybe it will, maybe it won't, but I have to at least try. Maybe at the end of the day, I will be left on the island by myself and the L87 community may get some resolution. I may just pull the engine out of the vehicle myself and rework it to my specs and move on, it would be the best of the evils. Replacement engine, rinse and repeat, not interested. Loose $25-$30k on the vehicle value just to get out from under it, I would rather pull the engine and sort it out myself, the vehicle value will still trash, but at least I would have a safe and reliable mode of transportation. Hell, if these things get totaled in a wreck, I wonder what insurance is paying out? If they track resale value we are all screwed. If you pay personal property tax, there is no relief based on loss of resale valve. And for anyone that is banking on any Extended Warranty to offer full coverage of a failed engines after the vehicle Powertrain Warranty has expired. Good luck I am sure every engine inspected will be flagged as an oil related failure and the Extended Warranty company will likely claim GM had a defect that they should not be responsible for. I hope I am wrong in the Extended Warranty side, but that money may not have been spent on what owners expected.
This is a very dynamic situation, while GM claims the crankshaft were the problem, what ever they did, if anything, made no change for the Post Recall engine or the Remans. The L87's are still dropping like flies. While I think the crankshaft machining and final finish may have have factored into this to a degree, this issue is really starting to look like many things are playing into what is going on. Kind of a perfect storm situation.
To back out to a 30,000 foot view of this total L87 debacle overall, at the basic and simplistic level this prolem is an oiling related problem. I do think and have the data to back everything that the way the L87 and TCM (Transmission Control Module) are tuned, and forgive me as they had combined at one point the ECU and TCM into what is considered a PCM (Powertrain Control Module) and this still may be the case, but I am focused on how the transmission programming is causing heavy Load spikes under minor grade elevation. While this Load Spiking is likely the trigger for the failures, many other things are contributing to the problem. Could/should the engine be able to survive this type of Load spiking, it should but the underlying sub systems all have to be able to support this behavior and I see a number of problem areas in the L86/L87 architecture. The L86 likely did not have level or Load spiking because it never had the 10 speed transmission from my research and the overall powertrain programming was not likely as agressive.
The problem at hand is most of the L87's in the wild likely have accelerated wear depending on how the vehicle was used and maintained, so what is the "Fix"?? This is the Billion Dollar question. We know what the first bite a the apple was, it did not work out so well. I expect the next bite may be attempting a software solution for a hardware/software related problem. Will this come to fruition?? My best guess what I know at this point is the entire L87 population that was originally Recalled, will be recalled AGAIN along with the late 2024-2026 models. I only have so many hours in the day, but I think the l87 may be in the large SUV's for 2027 while the pickups get the next generation 5.7l and 6.6l. Trust me, if I have something incorrect, someone will note my mistake and correct me quickly enough.
At the end of the day, 1,000,000 L87 owners are screwed in some way or another. If you happen to have a L87 that will run 300,000 miles without a problem great, but many won't. Resale values have tanked and likely will never recover because any recall will just barely improve the safety margin, but will not help reliability. Additionally the desirability of the L87 equipped products is really not there. What we can all be hopeful of is someone, and it will not likely be GM, finds out how to make an L87 last 300,000 miles, because with the loss of resale and desirability, even outside of Warranty, it may be wiser to throw money at the L87 if we know 100% it solves the weakness that is forcing so many of these vehicles to die on the highway.
Do I have an opinion and an I pissed, hell yea, I was hopeful this vehicle would last me 10-15+ years. It should and it could if the engine is configured correctly. Only time will tell if there is actually a reliable percentage of the L87 population, clearly the 2019-2021 appear at least on the surface to be better than 2022-date. Is there really anything different with the engine, machining, manufacturing?? We may never know.
But it seems likely oiling 101 is what is missing in these engines.
Sounds like Tow/Haul mode may help unload the engine some, hard to tell without a scan tool to watch the downshifts, but if in Tow/Haul mode downshifts earlier, then this may help these engines last longerI ran my 25 Expedition in Tow/Haul mode on my way to work today. It wouldn't shift into 10th gear until the vehicle hit 72 MPH. In normal mode, it hits 10th between 50 and 60.
I would be shocked if GM didn't have a program that allowed you to input RPM/load/temp/oil viscosity/oil pressure/bearing clearances and potentially other factors. It would be interesting to see what safety factors are used in worse case scenarios. I have to imagine that there is a whole group that does nothing but CFD analysis on oiling systems.@dgjtools
I cannot confirm or not if the Gen 2 10L80/10L90 went to the helical cut pump gears like Ford. I did a bunch of research and I could not confirm that the Gen 2 transmissions changed the pump gears, mine does not seem noisy to me, but I also have not been that deep into either my transmission or later Gen 2's to confirm what pump gears they typically have.
Here is my take on DFM and the bearing loadings, thousands or L87 with the DFM enabled have failed, additionally I think the DFM turns on and off very quickly to reduce eliminate vibration and the feeling of misfiring. Given the gradual grades I was encountering and how quickly the engine was loading up, I would have expected if DFM was enabled, it would have switched back to full 8 cylinder operation by the time the Load spiking started. Unfortunately I did not pull any data with and without the DFM module.
The more I look at L87 teardowns and what the bearings look like from online video, I am possibly on board with the crankshaft dimensional accuracy and bearing hardness playing into things a bit, but the more I look, the more I think this is really an inadequate oil film. Then add to everything DFM if operational and the Load spiking you have a recipe for disaster.
Here is my view of bearing spinning.
In order for a bearing to spin usually there is insufficient oiling then you end up getting into Mixed Mode or Boundary Layer lubrication. Layman's terms partial oiling/metal to metal contact or barely any oil and mostly metal to metal contact. Once there is too much friction between the spinning shaft/journal and the fixed bearing, the bearing will move/spin. If excessive loading is added or spiking loading then the friction will climb quickly and the bearing will likely spin even easier. The majority of the time if you are seeing over heated rods or main caps, the bearing has already spun and especially with Main bearings the oil hole is then blocked off and there is no more oil flow.
In some cases with excessive bearing wear you end up with too much bearing clearance, usually you see this reflected in an oil pressure loss and sometimes you can even hear bearing knocking. In these situations the oil wedge has a hard time staying alive because to much oil leakage from the larger bearing clearance.
I think these L87's tend to have premature bearing wear due to insufficient lubrication likely caused but variable displacement oil pump and sub par crank maching that leads to a lot of bearing scoring and some ovaling of the bearing shells then add the Low RPM with Severe Loading the L87 then is just put out of its misery.
Assuming this platform is consistent, the brakes are electrically assisted via the Brake Control Module, handles ABS and Power Assist as I recall.My 2019 6.2 L86 Gen 1 10L80 Yukon is the worst braking of any vehicle I have ever owned. Its like the brakes are undersized and it takes forever to stop. I have a 2016 5.3 L83 Tahoe with a 6 speed with identical brakes and it stops great. With the 10 speed, I always attributed the poor braking to the downshift (or lack there of) of the transmission. When I brake, I'm stopping the truck and are braking the engine at the same time.
Well this is part of the problem these days, too much reliance or modeling for Design, Reliability and even Production/QA.I would be shocked if GM didn't have a program that allowed you to input RPM/load/temp/oil viscosity/oil pressure/bearing clearances and potentially other factors. It would be interesting to see what safety factors are used in worse case scenarios. I have to imagine that there is a whole group that does nothing but CFD analysis on oiling systems.
Not sure where you numbers come from. A new L8T long block is about $7K and you can buy a complete crate engine for $8500. Guessing the L87 is just a long block.Well this is part of the problem these days, too much reliance or modeling for Design, Reliability and even Production/QA.
While models can and often are great, there are some pitfalls.
Models can be great when you have full control of the input variables and the input variables match the real world.
If you can vet a model 100% by comparing real world outcome and behavior, this is great.
But with any good model there are a few problems:
Bad assumptions Input = Bad results Output
Uncontrolled or unexpected/unaccounted for production or operational variables = Unexpected results Output.
I cannot say I know with 100% certainty what when wrong.
GM claims there were machining problems with the crankshaft and machining debris. Well 8-9 years and GM did not figured this out. GM did not do any QA on the crankshafts that were supplied? 3 internal GM investigations of these failures came up inconclusive?? Was GM relying solely on modeling and not the good old eyeball and and some basic measurement equipment?
I am now starting to suspect some sort of oil pressure/volume oscillation due to the Variable Displacement oil pump design and/or something left out with the 2nd Stage oil pump control. If there was adequate oil when and where it needed to be, this problem would not have been such a large percentage of failures on a fairly historically solid platform.
Load spiking as I have Logged, this is something that cannot be reproduced on an engine dyno or a chassis dyno very easily if at all. Even if an engine or chassis dyno could reproduce this behavior, someone needs to know if occurs and program for these types of rapid Load increased to see what happens internally in the engine.
Even if the models were well proven, it seems a good portion of high volume vehicles that are being sold are having similar problems. Are all manufacturers being impacted by the same things?? But it does make you stop and think what did all these manufacturers miss, I say real world test mules and not just on some closed course proving ground that does not mimic the real world very well.
You would hope that if GM had this figured out and implemented changes, their Reman engines would be better than the production engines but this does not appear to be the case.
Interesting thing I found the other day when poking around with regard to GM Reman engine pricing and core charges I found online. Seems the L87 price may have increased from what I was originally quoted.
L87 Reman $3,917.95 + 7,000 core charge.
L8T Reman $13,196.99 + 3,500 core charge, This is the cast iron block truck 6.6l
So it looks like GM is cooking the books from the bottom up, the L87 is almost $9,300 cheaper than the L8T and the L87 likely needs more money spent or at least has more damage to crank, rods and block than the L8T's that come in for Reman.
SMH
I was using an online dealer parts source. After your comment, I went back and tried to retrace my steps and somehow I screwed up. I was tying to get the L8T configuration and every time I was using most of the 2500 series trucks, the only option was the 6.6l Duramax. I finally found a configuration that appeared to give the 6.6l gas, but something did not go as expect. Not sure if it was the online part search or something cached in my browser, but clearly I did not get what I was after.Not sure where you numbers come from. A new L8T long block is about $7K and you can buy a complete crate engine for $8500. Guessing the L87 is just a long block.
Good question. I have not been able to confirm 100% but it appears the 2nd Stage solenoid is PWM controlled. Since I really am not running my vehicle at this point, I have not probed the control line.It appears there is allot of agreement that the electronically controlled oil pump to help meet cafe mpg could be part of the problem. Simple question but probably complex answer, is there a way to boost the 20ish idle oil pressure to say 30 or 35 with out completely changing the ecm mapping?
I just watched that video and came her to post it. Lake seems to agree with a lot of what you were saying. Good job.
I'll be doing some towing in about 10 day or so. I'll see if I notice any thing unusual with the oil pressure. The trip is from central OK to central IA, lots of hills. On a recent non towing trip, I did not notice any significant oil pressure changes, seemed to be holding fairly steady at ~55. That's a guesstimate since the gauge goes from 0-120 and the line was about 3/32-⅛ from the midpoint mark. That was in normal mode, so we'll see what tow/haul looks like, I don't recall anything odd during previous tow trips.Would also be interesting to see if the oil pressure control was more aggressive in Tow/Haul mode? Unfortunately I will not be able to validate on my vehicle.
Anyone with a 2025 or 2026 may be able to pull up the oil pressure gauge on the center display gauges and compare? Not sure if oil pressure on dash is buffered more than what is available by OBD port and I recall there may be a PID option for something like Absolute Oil Pressure or some sort?
Granted, but the major part of the problem here would be how many engine RpM under 'serious load', higher RpM being more desirableI found that if the Instant Fuel Economy drops to 8MpG or below, and the vertical bar graph is in the lower 25%, this is usually some serious loading on the engine.